HomeFloridaKey West, FL → NYAH

NYAH in Key West, FL

NYAH in Key West, FL


Not Your Average Hotel - An unconventional hotel experience for you and your entourage, posse, crew, or caravan of friends. NYAH is for people who travel together and stay together.

NYAH is an adult exclusive hotel located in the Key West Historic District. The property features a complimentary continental breakfast, 3 outdoor pools, and 2 Jacuzzis.

Free Wi-Fi and a flat-screen cable TV are provided in each room at NYAH. Balconies are provided in select suites.

Guests can walk through the garden or ask the tour desk for area recommendations. The 24-hour front desk provides luggage storage.


Established in 2014.

The brainchild of hospitality innovators --and brothers-- Jesper and Gustaf Arnoldsson, NYAH was conceptualized after they asked themselves the question, "Who said there should only be two people to a room?" The idea for NYAH became apparent after noticing groups of friends like to share a room, not only because it's more affordable, but because it's more fun and allows guests the option of staying at a higher quality hotel for the same or lower price per person. Together, Jesper and Gustaf felt that the needs of this emerging "sharing generation" were being overlooked by the hotel industry--six years later the NYAH concept was born.


Company Info:

Rating: 4.38

Address: 420 Margaret St, Key West, FL, 33040
  • Mon: Open 24 hours
  • Tue: Open 24 hours
  • Wed: Open 24 hours
  • Thu: Open 24 hours
  • Fri: Open 24 hours
  • Sat: Open 24 hours
  • Sun: Open 24 hours

Hotels in Key West, FL



Comments (13):

1. Alvaro A.
This hotel is actually very, very good. The staff is absolutely fantastic, very pleasant and clean place and within walking distance from EVERYTHING. A gem in key west, I would definitely stay here again without a doubt.

15/09/14 | Link | Rating: 5.0
2. Alexander B.
This place went downhill fast when the new owners took over. I don't recommend it and I'll never stay here again.

11/11/14 | Link | Rating: 1.0
3. Robert S.
Stumbled across this place on hotel booking site.   Did we luck out. Clean, quiet, wonderful staff. Walk up the street to Duval  close to everything ,  will definitely stay here again.

16/08/14 | Link | Rating: 4.0
4. Wee T.
I was here for 2 nights. Everything was perfect !!! The place is beautiful, nice and quiet. I will definitely coming back and tell all my friends to stay.

05/12/14 | Link | Rating: 5.0
5. David C.
I stayed here for three nights with a bachelor party. We had right people total, and for our purposes this place was perfect. Two nice pools. A strong playlist. The rooms were clean and in good repair. I would 100% recommend this place to groups or large families.

22/04/15 | Link | Rating: 5.0
6. Andrea D.
Absolutely loved NYAH! One of the best places I have ever stayed in. The customer service is superb. Everyone was super friendly and very accommodating. The free wine and cheese happy hour is a huge plus! (And the free breakfast too.) I highly recommend this place to anyone traveling to key west.

14/04/15 | Link | Rating: 5.0
7. Emily H.
This place is awesome. From the moment you walk in and are greeted by friendly employees to the free Starbucks coffee you can get at any hour. Our room was perfect for us to rest our heads, 2 bunk beds with extremely clean and comfortable bedding. The mattresses were top notch also, I had such a great night sleep!! The only reason I'm not giving a perfect rating was because of the floor in our room. My feet were black just from walking around on it :0/
Other than that the place was gorgeous and had such an awesome layout. They don't put up with loud noise all night either, quiet time was 9pm and it was spring break!

18/03/15 | Link | Rating: 4.0
8. Natasha D.
Love, love, love this place! Marcy is a doll. Staff is super friendly and patient. Beautiful property.
The best part is the inclusive wine and cheese happy hour..unlimited. Fantastic!
This place somewhat resembles a hostel as there are beds that fold out of the walls and lockable closets. I totally get it though, it's key west. You could be shacked up with random people or bring someone untrustworthy home.
The only complaint is that the door keys keep breaking or not working. It happened to us 3 times and I saw it happen to a few other guests as well. But the front desk was quick to correct it.
Breakfast is also pretty bland with some fruit and toast, so we just went to Pepe's which rules.
I will definitely be back her very soon. Great value, great service! Very fun!

22/09/14 | Link | Rating: 5.0
9. Jamie M.
Odd hotel - more like a hostel . Really pretty on the outside but rooms lack a lot . My room merely had a couple sets of bunk beds and a few lockers . Our room did have wall nooks for usb phone charging,  which I found odd for such a simple room . The courtyard is beautiful ! There are 2 pools and a hot tub for you to enjoy . It feels more like a boutique resort on the outside and like a dorm on the inside. The ability to pile in the people to split room fees with all the bunk beds is a plus though . For Key West lodging close to the strip -it's the cheaper way to go. I suppose the amenities and location are a trade off for the lack luster rooms. I'd stay there again for the price .

06/05/15 | Link | Rating: 3.0
10. Andrea L.
Absolutely LOVED my stay at NYAH. Couldn't have asked for a better experience if I tried--bathrooms are top notch, every type of pool you could desire, free wine and cheese happy hour every day, free Starbucks coffee machine and Tazo teas available 24/7, and the invitation to come back to relax and store our luggage at the hotel even after checking out. Staff is super friendly and helpful. Making this my go-to hotel in the Keys and definitely will be back many times!

13/05/15 | Link | Rating: 5.0
11. Ian S.
Stayed here for a friends 21st birthday. Staff was very accommodating and friendly. The room was nice and clean and the beds were comfortable. The hotel is pretty modern and has outlets and USB slots right next to the bed. There's two pools and a jacuzzi in the middle of the grounds. Its a great place to relax and catch some sun. They even have a roof top sun deck. And the best part?

Unlimited wine and cheese from 4:20-6:00. It also considerably close to Duval St. and easy to get to and from the bar area.

I would definitely stay here again.

19/12/14 | Link | Rating: 5.0
12. Danielle G.
This place has the BEST front desk staff hands down.  Stayed two nights for girlfriend birthday weekend with 6 women.  Loved the room, the pools/hot tubs, bedding and everything about NYAH.  Will stay again next Key West trip.  It's location is excellent.   Not too close, not too far from Duval and Key West Express.  

Wine reception with cheese is daily.  Nice touch!  Continental breakfast is a true Continental breakfast.  Simple, but will get you started out right.  

Tip:  Rooms close to pool means not having to drag luggage some lofty stairs.

31/01/15 | Link | Rating: 5.0
13. Shaun R.
What an awesome idea for a hotel. Gone is everything you don't need in your room and yet you still have all the comforts and luxuries you could ever want in a stay. Frank and staff is super friendly and beyond helpful and bike rentals make getting around Key West a breeze. Highly recommend and hope to be back soon!

For full review, write up and pictures see here: thislifeintrips.com/nyah…

26/02/15 | Link | Rating: 5.0